Returning once more to Westeros, when Tyrion killed his longtime girlfriend Shae, it was a terrible, ghastly, and heartbreaking moment, but by then not only did we have the fact that they allowed this relationship to bake and grow over a few seasons so that we understand the power and the meaning of her betrayal to him, but we were also given more than enough insight into Tyrion's character and what ultimately forms his makeup over several seasons in a number of nonviolent decisions that he makes and even more still in dialogue and monologue that informs us as to what drives him, what he's willing to do, what his place is in the world is, and how he sees himself and others. So that we understand that class ,misogyny, pain, ego, and love all play a role in the act. The mission that the writers have of trying to gather the audience to empathize somewhat with Tyrion as a character is accomplished, despite the fact that we know he is capable problematic and at times cruel behavior. The same could be said for “Omar” from The Wire (another character played by Michael K Williams) despite the fact that we see him murder, snitch, and betray those close to him, like Tyrion he ends up one of the most revered and beloved characters in television history. The character of Montrose in Lovecraft Country received none of that care or craft, representationally he mattered, but nowhere else it seems, and since we know the capabilities of the actor, and we also know that no one is arguing that certain identities are incapable of bad poor behavior, then ultimately what we are left with is the fact that the anger is due to the poor characterization and the abrupt and at times sadistic behavior of said characters. This is where I come back to the “Impossible First”. “Firsts” are often influential, salient, and symbolic, but they are rarely as exceptional as what comes after them. They don’t have the benefit of having those who came before dig a clear pathway, or falter by way of unseen boobie traps and pitfalls. I use the word impossible because it speaks to the tenuous relationship between being the first, the meaning of being the first to do anything or represent anything, and the inherent complications and failings of being the first to represent or do anything. Often times Firsts are intentionally too measured (Obama) and may become paralyzed somewhere between doing too little and too much, or (as is my own personal theory for Lovecraft ) caught trying to do too much and be everything to everybody all in one go. In this way it becomes like the basketball player on the free throw line realizing He/She/They've got one shot left with the weight and the implications of the past and the future right there in front of them in one basket. Pressure causing him/her/they to either put too much on the ball or put too little. As many of those former and present greats who performed exceptionally under pressure have said, the best place to be in your mind here is focused on technique and execution, and nothing else. This is why I think it is a mistake to focus so much on the pitfalls of proper representation and am always of the mind that the two most important aspects of filmmaking and telling stories to either the medium of television or film are simultaneously story and collaboration. If you're not focused on the execution, the technique, the authenticity (which comes from and extends out from the collaboration aspect ) of the story that you're telling then the very thing you intend to do by way of representation will always fall short, and the weight of being the first will hobble and potentially cripple you. Right along side story and inextricable from is collaboration. It is maybe first and foremost beginning with collaborating in the writers room with those of the identity with which you wish to represent via Barry Jenkins and Tarell Alvin McCraney in the case of “Moonlight”, and then subsequently to allowing your actors of various identities to shape and form by weight of their inherent self add weight, depth, and understanding as to who this character is. I may very well be overly optimistic in my belief that the creator and writer of this show truly lost their way and misstepped in the first season and that most of these problems are very correctable, but I also believe it's fair to look at some of the obstacles that might have made it difficult for the writers to hone in on exactly what it is they wanted to accomplish not only with the idea of being the first, but then the weight of trying to be the first to introduce representation of various peoples and folks in a genre that they previously had rarely if at all been invited to in the middle Peak television where so many are competing for the eyeballs of a extremely distracted audience. I understand the temptation and the desire to make a show where every episode whizzes and bangs so that the audience is always left gasping, shocked, and in awe of what happened especially when you know that in your inaugural season you don't have the kind of rope that those shows with well-established white creators and/or built-in IP's may have. So I for one will be waiting and holding out hope that they will now having at least accomplished the fact that they are a hit now get to the business of focusing strapping down to give these characters and this story the space, the time, the care to breathe and ferment into a fine wine, now having graduated beyond the impossible first and into the very possible next.