Lovecraft County and The Impossible First

1_m5hZcV3VcyyTBkaIcBtTNQ.jpeg

When the first episode of a show is the height of its popularity and execution with me ( as well as with many others ) that’s usually means I’m about to lay into something…hard, but with Lovecraft Country (unlike the treatment of the material) my feelings are complex. It was new territory for the characters in the show, new territory for the audiences, and in many ways new territory for black people depicted on screen genre, but was that new territory enough? No…but also yes, but also its alot. In many ways the show failed its audience in so many categories it’s a wonder it wasn't protested in the streets. The story was all over the place, ( there was a very common joke about how no one could explain what the show was about to anyone else) the pacing was off, characterization was weak, there were complaints of colorism, homophobia, transphobia, and the ending was as largely “WTF”as so many of its other memorable moments for the wrong reasons. The things is though that A. I would argue that none of that is stopping very many people from tuning into season 2, and B. Argue that the reason why is all of those things only happen because of the real reason the show didnt work ..It felt rushed. Every single problem this show has in my estimation extends out fron this source code issue. Nothing and I mean NOTHING was given time to bake, to sit and be still, to soak in. You look at a character like Atticus (Tic) and it was “Hey his Dad is dead, and Oops your uncle is too, and hey wait no your Dad is alive, and hey hes gay, but oh no he’s abusive, and then he was never really your father at all" and that’s just Atticus. That is way too much arc for one season especially when they're are several other characters in the show. Add that this would be the way backstory, arc, and representation would be for every single character in the show, and it became so much that I began to sing the lyrics to John Mayer's “Stop this train”.

“Stop this train, I want to get off and go home again
I can’t take the speed it’s moving in, I know I can’t, but, honestly, won’t someone stop this train?”

Go down the line of characters whether they were at the top of the social stratification of black folk and other marginalized identities or near the bottom, and the one unifying aspect across the board is that none of them are given the space to grow significantly, and for us to know them significantly. If you asked me to tell you who Tic is, what makes him (pardon the pun) “tick” what his motivations are, why he embarks on this journey, I couldn’t tell you anything that isn’t or wasn’t superficial. He was in the military, but how did that affect him? Sure theres PTSD but what kind of man did it shape him to be ? This is a man who killed innocent people without pause, ( as we were shown in the shows best episode which took place during the Korean war during a flashback) and yet there was no meaningful scene in which we see the way that affects his mind later. Nothing meaningful is said about his relationship with Leti, his deeply traumatic relationship with his father is reduced to him yelling alot. Things with Tic and his father are shred apart and put back together with the kind of care Jim Carrey gave to that parcel in the opening credits of Ace Ventura pet detective.

Good characterization should tell us not only what motivates characters on an intrinsic level, but reveal the ways in which these intrinsic motivations and qualities move the script and bare consequence on their lives. In this case then it also becomes important for the writers to have a sort of clear grip on the type of show you intend to be and how best to become that. A simplified example could be the difference between a show driven by events, or a show driven by characters. One does not displace the meaningfulness of having the other but it does inform the foundation of your work - that being the place from where everything else receives its strength. To place it upon a foundation not well-suited for the type of building you intend to erect is to set it up for a fall. Big nuanced and complex narratives about the nature of various forms of “otherness” or traits and arcs that defy one understanding or perception cannot be built upon the same foundation as a show like “The Mandolarian” Where it’s less about character and more about the adventure itself and how it shapes the character. It should be like “Killing Eve” or “The Wire" where the characters shape the arc of the story, by way of their wants and needs. Every character in Lovecraft seemed to move based on plot contrivances in a form of authorial determinism. The characters ended up in certain places, and took certain actions because the writers clearly deemed it their fate. This is of course is always the way with writing but the idea should be to erase the strings so that it appears that the characters are moving based upon their own intuitions and instincts. With Lovecraft not only were the strings seemingly visible, but the puppeteers too. Take Ruby for example, who seems to have ended up where she ended up, because the writers said so, which then opened the writers up for the criticism that it was owing to her skin tone as a clear precedent and long history exists for that exact thing. Ruby's decision to wear white skin and to side with a white woman over her own sister is gross negligence not because it could never be a decision made by a black woman, but because considering the depth of the kind of betrayal of self hatred that would lead to such a decision, then you need that much more of an understanding of Ruby's history, mentality, and desires. This makes it clear the source of the problem happened before she even made this decision and it's in the fact that the writers never took the time to in any meaningful way inform the audience as to who Rudy is, or what she wants, and when we take a look at the other characters the same goes for them which at least in my humble opinion at least makes it more difficult to make this purely the form of being singled out that colorism is. To put it simply colorism and the other various “isms” maybe symptoms of the shows problem but they are not the virus that caused it. This being a problem because if we the audience tell the writers that the symptoms are the core issues then they end up providing what will be temporarily fixes like so much cough syrup to the common cold, only to have the virus still cause problems that will eventually lead to the return of a lot of these very problems or the creation of new ones.

wunmi-mosaku-lovecraft-country-episode-7-855x570.jpg

None of this erases the fact that there were times in Lovecraft’s 10 episodes where it was clear that the writers had blind spots towards the identities that they were trying to give representation to, but blind spots are a by- product of the limitations of attention. Since our focus can only see within a limited range and depth of field the spaces just around the edges are holes waiting to be filled by our focus. Re-prioritizing focus provides a clear path to avoiding some of the dense brush and bramble that one could cut oneself up on while trying to write a show handling such complex themes, narratives, and identities. This upcoming season (provided there is one..it seems safe to assume so) writers should take advantage of the strengths of long-form storytelling and take a page from shows like “The Wire” and “Game of Thrones” which also dealt with similar complex teams like race, class, and systemic oppression in the case of “The Wire” or political intrigue and identity in the case of “Game of Thrones”. In long form storytelling its clearly about taking advantage of the time you have, and not rushing things to get to the next big event. The folly in the misrepresentation of the “Two-Spirit” character Yahima that caused so much controversy came as a result of not only a blind spot, but a lack of time and focus. It could be argued that its possible the lack of time caused the blind spot, (though most likely the two are inextricable) still, given more time to set up and bake the arc of let’s say a Yahima, that character ends up faring much better, and maybe the backlash ends up sounding more like fine tuning, rather than righteous disappointment by an audience already far too beleaguered by poor representation or the lack of any at all.

processed_pedro-pascal.jpg


In looking back at the “The Viper” Oberyn Martell from GOT, we have a model somewhat similar to Yahima in the superficial sense that his death came suddenly and without warning. It would have felt relatively ridiculous to have his arc condensed into just one episode where his very sudden and abrupt death is the ending. Of course it would not have the added representational harm that came from Yahima's death, but it would have been terrible nonetheless. Instead with only 4 episodes the writers gave us enough background, objectives, and motivational understanding of Oberyn to know and understand why he died without feeling like we were cheated. Oberyn over the four episodes is proven to be charming, protective, proud, arrogant, and then finally skilled, but it was his arrogance and his pride that got him killed. What was Yahima's flaw? Did she have one? Is she a pure victim? If not where was she blind? What motivation did she have that might have as a point of pure objective consequence or karma played a role in her demise? We dont know, because we dont know Yahima at all. The unique character opportunity that she was, she was alive for all of a commercial break before she was brutally dispatched by Tic's surrogate abuser Montrose Freeman in the name of protection. We then arrive at the double-headedness of the problem because we also have to deal with who killed Yahima. Unlike with the Viper, it is not simply a mountainous scoundrel but a supposedly good character, and for reasons that again are hard to explain except by way of knowing the events calendar. With the character of Montrose you see again the failing of allowing the events or what has happened to the characters to be the sole explanation of who they are. The rather heinous killing of Yahima is wrapped up in the event Montrose is trying to stop from happening and what has happened to Montrose himself, but the issue is being abused is not an excuse of the act, nor a good explanation of the nature that would use someone to commit it.

LOVECRAFT-COUNTRY-104-RECAP.jpg

Returning once more to Westeros, when Tyrion killed his longtime girlfriend Shae, it was a terrible, ghastly, and heartbreaking moment, but by then not only did we have the fact that they allowed this relationship to bake and grow over a few seasons so that we understand the power and the meaning of her betrayal to him, but we were also given more than enough insight into Tyrion's character and what ultimately forms his makeup over several seasons in a number of nonviolent decisions that he makes and even more still in dialogue and monologue that informs us as to what drives him, what he's willing to do, what his place is in the world is, and how he sees himself and others. So that we understand that class ,misogyny, pain, ego, and love all play a role in the act. The mission that the writers have of trying to gather the audience to empathize somewhat with Tyrion as a character is accomplished, despite the fact that we know he is capable problematic and at times cruel behavior. The same could be said for “Omar” from The Wire (another character played by Michael K Williams) despite the fact that we see him murder, snitch, and betray those close to him, like Tyrion he ends up one of the most revered and beloved characters in television history. The character of Montrose in Lovecraft Country received none of that care or craft, representationally he mattered, but nowhere else it seems, and since we know the capabilities of the actor, and we also know that no one is arguing that certain identities are incapable of bad poor behavior, then ultimately what we are left with is the fact that the anger is due to the poor characterization and the abrupt and at times sadistic behavior of said characters. This is where I come back to the “Impossible First”. “Firsts” are often influential, salient, and symbolic, but they are rarely as exceptional as what comes after them. They don’t have the benefit of having those who came before dig a clear pathway, or falter by way of unseen boobie traps and pitfalls. I use the word impossible because it speaks to the tenuous relationship between being the first, the meaning of being the first to do anything or represent anything, and the inherent complications and failings of being the first to represent or do anything. Often times Firsts are intentionally too measured (Obama) and may become paralyzed somewhere between doing too little and too much, or (as is my own personal theory for Lovecraft ) caught trying to do too much and be everything to everybody all in one go. In this way it becomes like the basketball player on the free throw line realizing He/She/They've got one shot left with the weight and the implications of the past and the future right there in front of them in one basket. Pressure causing him/her/they to either put too much on the ball or put too little. As many of those former and present greats who performed exceptionally under pressure have said, the best place to be in your mind here is focused on technique and execution, and nothing else. This is why I think it is a mistake to focus so much on the pitfalls of proper representation and am always of the mind that the two most important aspects of filmmaking and telling stories to either the medium of television or film are simultaneously story and collaboration. If you're not focused on the execution, the technique, the authenticity (which comes from and extends out from the collaboration aspect ) of the story that you're telling then the very thing you intend to do by way of representation will always fall short, and the weight of being the first will hobble and potentially cripple you. Right along side story and inextricable from is collaboration. It is maybe first and foremost beginning with collaborating in the writers room with those of the identity with which you wish to represent via Barry Jenkins and Tarell Alvin McCraney in the case of “Moonlight”, and then subsequently to allowing your actors of various identities to shape and form by weight of their inherent self add weight, depth, and understanding as to who this character is. I may very well be overly optimistic in my belief that the creator and writer of this show truly lost their way and misstepped in the first season and that most of these problems are very correctable, but I also believe it's fair to look at some of the obstacles that might have made it difficult for the writers to hone in on exactly what it is they wanted to accomplish not only with the idea of being the first, but then the weight of trying to be the first to introduce representation of various peoples and folks in a genre that they previously had rarely if at all been invited to in the middle Peak television where so many are competing for the eyeballs of a extremely distracted audience. I understand the temptation and the desire to make a show where every episode whizzes and bangs so that the audience is always left gasping, shocked, and in awe of what happened especially when you know that in your inaugural season you don't have the kind of rope that those shows with well-established white creators and/or built-in IP's may have. So I for one will be waiting and holding out hope that they will now having at least accomplished the fact that they are a hit now get to the business of focusing strapping down to give these characters and this story the space, the time, the care to breathe and ferment into a fine wine, now having graduated beyond the impossible first and into the very possible next.